The local sports radio morning guys asked an interesting question this morning, “Do you trust Ted Thompson with the draft?” Why do I find it interesting? Well, I’m not the biggest Ted supporter in the world. I think there are 3 tools at your disposal when building a team in the NFL:
- The draft
- Trades
- Free Agency
Ted seems to try to see if he can build a team using #1 only. Why would you do that? But, its a good thing for Ted he’s pretty decent at that option otherwise he’d be unemployed.
So, do I trust him? Yep. Except for the first round maybe. Aaron Rodgers was a gift that he was smart enough not to screw up. I remember listening to that draft on the radio when it became the Packers pick. I was actually standing in my yard with a shovel full of dirt shouting at the radio, “You better take Rodgers!” He did, and I calmed down. Next came A.J. Hawk. He was a safe pick. Someone who could start for your team for a long time, but he never looked like he’d be special. He continues to look that way. A top five draft pick needs to be special or you didn’t get enough value for your pick. Next up, Justin Harrell. Well, so far the 2,000+ folks in the Lambeau Atrium who booed Thompson when he drafted him appear to have been right. Last year, Thompson got wiser and traded out of the first round lest he screw up another first round pick.
Which brings us to this year. I’ve stated that I’d like to see them draft Raji. I know there might be some character/motivation concerns there but he’s upside is tremendous and that’s what you’re looking for drafting high and paying that big salary before they ever step foot on a field. No risk, no reward.
But, if I had to pick I think Thompson will take one of Everette Brown, Andre Smith, or Tyson Jackson. I know Jackson has the perfect body to play DE in the 3-4, but in that scheme it’s generally not a position you spend a lot of money on. Plus, a month ago no one knew who he was and he suddenly comes flying up the boards? Those guys always scare me because they tend to be “look like Tarzan, play like Jane” workout warriors with great measurables. It’s the exception that those guys can actually play at the next level. Brown is a defensive lineman from Florida State. Maybe switching him to an OLB in the 3-4 might be a way to get around that schools history of bad D-linemen in the NFL.
But, if it came down to those guys I’d take Smith. He fits a need at tackle and started three years in the SEC. I know, he showed up way out of shape at the combine and left early. He needs to grow up a bit. But, the SEC is not an easy place to play OT, and he started there for 3 years and did a pretty darn good job doing it. He’s a RT in the NFL and I think he’s better than any option the Packers currently have on their roster. And remember folks, you build from the line out, not the other way around.
So, there’s my pick, Andre Smith RT from Alabama. Although, I’d be happier if they took B.J. Raji, DT from Boston College. Tune in tomorrow around 4:15 when the Pack makes their pick and see if I’m anywhere in the ball park.